Pfizer-Allergan megamerger report prompts speculation about fallout for CROs

By Staff reporter

- Last updated on GMT

Pfizer-Allergan deal report prompts speculation about fallout for CROs

Related tags: Pfizer

Reports Pfizer is considering buying Allergan to create a company worth $330bn have once again raised fears of disruption for contract research organisations (CRO), although there are reasons to think the deal would be less troublesome than earlier megamergers.

If the deal, news of which was broken by the Wall Street Journal​,​ goes ahead it will create a massive drugmaker with a R&D budget of around $9bn (€8.2bn) a year. The last time Pfizer and its peers entered into such deals, the resulting reprioritisation of pipelines and restructuring of operations played havoc with bookings at the CROs that worked with the companies involved.

However, while there is precedent from 2008 and 2009 of the near-term harm megamergers can cause to CROs, there are also reasons to think the combination of Pfizer and Allergan would have a more benign effect on the industry than these earlier deals.

Tim Evans, senior analyst at Wells Fargo, laid out some reasons for optimism in a note to investors. Cancellations, a common negative side effect of large client mergers, are unlikely to be as damaging as in the past because Pfizer, Allergan and CROs are different than their equivalents in earlier deals.

Evans is unsure on Allergan’s approach to outsourcing, but given that the current iteration of the company has been created through a flurry of large takeovers, it is reasonable to assume the firm has a patchwork of legacy vendors and in-house teams.

If this is the case, the effect of any post-merger cancellations will be spread across a large number of CROs, meaning no one service provider will be hit particularly hard. In contrast, the 2008-2009 deals involved pharma companies that sent a lot of work to a small number of CROs.

CROs are also better equipped to cope with cancellations than in the past. “The large, public CROs have significantly more scale today than during the last round of large pharma mergers. We believe the disruption from any one cancellation has been significantly diluted by scale​,” Evans said.

Long-term optimism

Even if the merger were to cause some near-term disruption for CROs, there is evidence to suggest that some service providers would benefit once the integration is complete. “Vendors of the acquirer tend to fare well over a longer horizon as combinations lead to more outsourcing​,” Evans said.

In this scenario, Icon, Parexel and PPD, the three CROs that capture most of Pfizer’s late-stage R&D spending, would benefit. The benefits will be particularly pronounced if, as Evans believes, Allergan currently sends a smaller proportion of its R&D budget to CROs than Pfizer and the merger therefore leads to increased outsourcing penetration.

Whatever the situation today, it is unlikely the combination of Allergan, a company renowned for its lean R&D operation, and Pfizer, with its track record of post-acquisition layoffs, will create a firm that favours in-house teams over CROs.  

Related news

Show more

Related products

show more

Import Risks & Clinical Supply Depots

Import Risks & Clinical Supply Depots

Catalent Pharma Solutions | 07-Nov-2018 | Case Study

A sponsor running a clinical trial in Israel arranged to ship their clinical trial product from Europe to a depot in Israel. With the protocol based in...

Manufacturing Cyto and Non-Cyto Drugs in One Facility

Manufacturing Cyto and Non-Cyto Drugs in One Facility

Baxter BioPharma Solutions | 05-Nov-2018 | Technical / White Paper

Recent market reports suggest increasing product niches, which may lead to decreasing numbers of units per product, making dedicated facilities less practical....

Baxter’s Oncology Contract Manufacturing

Baxter’s Oncology Contract Manufacturing

Baxter BioPharma Solutions | 29-Aug-2018 | Product Brochure

Baxter BioPharma Solutions’ FOYA award-winning facility in Halle/Westfalen, Germany, offers state-of-the-art parenteral cGMP manufacturing at one location,...

Discover Fermion’s new API unit 4 in Hanko

Discover Fermion’s new API unit 4 in Hanko

Recorded the 04-Sep-2018 | Webinar

Join this webinar to learn more about Fermion’s new manufacturing unit 4 at the Hanko site. This webinar will provide virtual tour to our new state of...

Related suppliers

Follow us

Featured Events

View more


View more