ASCO 2019

Relaxed eligibility criteria would double patient numbers in lung cancer studies: ASCO

By Melissa Fassbender contact

- Last updated on GMT

(Image: Getty/millionsjoker)
(Image: Getty/millionsjoker)

Related tags: ASCO, Clinical trials, Patient recruitment

Broader clinical trial eligibility criteria would double patient numbers in lung cancer studies, according to a new report from ASCO, which has been leading efforts to expand access to oncology clinical trials.

According to David Graham, MD, FACP, FASCO, medical director at the Levine Cancer Institute, restrictive eligibility criteria is one of the reasons for low clinical trial participation numbers – which for cancer patients in the US is approximately 3%.

The American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO) study released ​this week during the organization’s annual meeting “makes the case for universal adoption of broader clinical trial eligibility criteria,”​ Graham said in a statement.

The study examined 10,500 health records of advanced non-small cell lung cancer (aNSCLC) patients from ASCO’s CancerLinQ​ database.

Per the report, expanded criteria – such as that proposed by ASCO and Friends of Cancer Research (Friends) in 2017 to include patients with brain metastases, previous or concurrent cancers, and limited kidney function – would nearly double the percentage of patients eligible to participate in clinical trials, from 52.3% to 98.5%.

Traditional clinical trial enrollment criteria excluded 5,005 (47.7% of patients), while the only 154 (1.5% of patients) did not meet eligibility criteria using the expanded conditions, the study found.

Additionally, ASCO reported that expanded criteria would permit more women, older patients, and those with stage IV diagnoses, as well as non-smokers, to enroll in aNSCLC clinical trials.

Lead author of the study, R. Donald Harvey, PharmD, BCOP, FCCP, FHOPA, director of the Winship Cancer Institute of Emory University’s Phase I Clinical Trials Section, explained that changes to eligibility criteria “are particularly important as we step further into the era of targeted therapies, including immunotherapies, that have different safety profiles than highly toxic systemic chemotherapies.”

“Ongoing use of historic, narrow eligibility criteria based on antiquated safety concerns place potentially unnecessary restrictions on trial participants, thus making it increasingly difficult to conduct the clinical trials necessary to demonstrate safety and efficacy of new therapies,”​ he said in the press release.

Efforts to expand access

Based on the proposal from ASCO and Friends, the National Cancer Institute (NCI) in November 2018 changed its clinical trial protocol template​ to expand patient access, though, according to ASCO, it is too early to tell if the expanded criteria is being widely adopted.

The organizations initiated the joint project aimed at evolving eligibility criteria in 2016 and submitted language in August 2018 for five US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) guidance documents. The agency subsequently published​ four draft guidances and one final guidance addressing cancer clinical trial eligibility criteria in March of this year.

Read: FDA eases ‘unnecessarily restrictive’ cancer clinical trial eligibility criteria

The Response Assessment in Neuro-Oncology – Brain Metastases (RANO-BM) group, an international, multidisciplinary group working to develop standard response and progression criteria for clinical trials, also in early 2018 published new guidelines​ describing how to address cancer patients with CNS involvement in anti-cancer drug studies.

The lead author told us at the time that the guidelines were developed in response to the “inappropriate exclusion​” of patients whose cancer has spread to their brain, but which wouldn’t affect the study’s outcome.

Related news

Show more

Related products

show more

Laboratory Solutions for COVID-19 Clinical Trials

Laboratory Solutions for COVID-19 Clinical Trials

Q2 Solutions | 10-Jun-2020 | Clinical Study

As a leading laboratory services organization for trials across the globe, we are proud to partner with clients to support COVID-19 clinical trials. Our...

Parents as Gatekeepers for Children with Cancer

Parents as Gatekeepers for Children with Cancer

PRA Health Sciences | 08-Jun-2020 | Technical / White Paper

The RACE for Children Act will require new drugs intended for adult cancer treatment to also be studied in pediatric cancers when the molecular target...

RACE Act Prompts Pediatric Oncology Trials

RACE Act Prompts Pediatric Oncology Trials

PRA Health Sciences | 04-May-2020 | Technical / White Paper

Many providers prescribe drugs off-label to pediatric patients, even though there have been few pediatric trials for many of these drugs. In response,...

Manufacturing Cyto and Non-Cyto Drugs in One Facility

Manufacturing Cyto and Non-Cyto Drugs in One Facility

Baxter BioPharma Solutions | 01-Mar-2020 | Technical / White Paper

Recent market reports suggest increasing product niches, which may lead to decreasing numbers of units per product, making dedicated facilities less practical....

Related suppliers

Follow us


View more