Too transparent or too opaque: EMA clinical trial data plans criticised

Too transparent or too opaque: EMA trial data plans criticised

Related tags European union Clinical trial

The EMA is being criticised on two fronts with some suggesting its trial data publication plans will drive away drug R&D while others argue the agency is backtracking in a way that will hinder public health research.  

The European Medicines Agency's (EMA) management board meets today to discuss its draft implementation policy​ on the publication of clinical trial data.

Industry critics suggest recently passed draft European laws​ that would force drugmakers to publish summaries of ongoing trials and full reports if the drug under investigation is approved are a disincentive to innovation that will drive R&D away from the EU and endanger international intellectual property agreements.

Among those taking this stand is the US Chamber of Commerce, which put out a study concluding​ that no other countries outside the EU are taking such a stance on transparency or seeking to emulate the EMA, and these policies may cause unintended consequences.

The policies may “result in placing commercially confidential information into the public domain not only in the EU but also internationally​,” the CoC says.

A number of countries and legal jurisdictions predicate the protection of information on that information not already being in the public domain​.”

The EMA’s publication of clinical trials data puts this information in the public domain and “raises uncertainties about whether or not the information retains its confidential or undisclosed character in countries such as Malaysia​,” or elsewhere that might replicate the actions of the agency, the Chamber says.

Not enough transparency?

Other critics say the EMA's implementation plan does not go far enough with campaigning group AllTrials arguing​ that the proposal to only allow researchers to view data online and not take copies will limit their ability to carry out re-analysis of medicines post approval.

European Ombudsman​ Emily O'Reilly voiced similar worries earlier this week.

"I am now concerned about what appears to be a significant change in EMA's policy, which could undermine the fundamental right of public access to documents established by EU law. European citizens, doctor and researchers need maximum information about the medicines they take, prescribe and analyse​."

In response, Guido Rasi, EMA Executive Director, said: “I remain open-minded and will explore with the Board possible alternative approaches, especially more user-friendly ways of providing access to data and meeting the reasonable expectations of academics and researchers​.”

The EMA “has also publicly recognised the potential benefits for public health of independent re-analysis of data by independent academics and researchers after a medicine has been approved, and acknowledged that regulators do not have a monopoly on science​,” the agency said, highlighting a recent editorial from the New England Journal of Medicine​.

Related news

Show more

Related products

show more

Using Define-XML to build more efficient studies

Using Define-XML to build more efficient studies

Content provided by Formedix | 14-Nov-2023 | White Paper

It is commonly thought that Define-XML is simply a dataset descriptor: a way to document what datasets look like, including the names and labels of datasets...

Overcoming rapid growth challenges with process liquid preparation

Overcoming rapid growth challenges with process liquid preparation

Content provided by Thermo Fisher Scientific - Process Liquid Preparation Services | 01-Nov-2023 | Case Study

A growing contract development manufacturing organization (CDMO) was challenged with the need to quickly expand their process liquid and buffer preparation...

Why should you use clinical trial technology?

Why should you use clinical trial technology?

Content provided by Formedix | 01-Nov-2023 | White Paper

New, innovative clinical trial technology is helping to revolutionize the research landscape. COVID-19 demonstrated that clinical trials can be run much...

Related suppliers

Follow us


View more